Singles, sealed and supplies from Irving Park, Chicago

Magic the Gathering Buylist

You're currently browsing our buylist ← Return to Store

Sell Magic the Gathering MTG cards to Near Mint Games. This buylist shows what the store pays for each card in cash or store credit.

Browse Magic the Gathering categories

1 category

What we pay for Magic the Gathering cards

The buylist on this page covers 12 cards, with offers from $5.17 up to $54.65. The best-paying cards include Cavern of Souls ($54.65), Mana Vault ($51.74) and Wall of Air ($42.83).

How to sell your cards

Bring your cards to the store at 4023 W Irving Park in Chicago, ideally sorted by set. We check each one against our card condition standards, and offers assume the condition stated on the list. Store credit offers are usually higher than cash.

Buying rather than selling? Our Magic the Gathering MTG cards are listed with price and condition.

Frequently asked questions

How do I sell Magic the Gathering cards?

Bring them to Near Mint Games at 4023 W Irving Park in Chicago. The store checks condition and pays cash or store credit, with credit offers usually higher than cash.

What is the most valuable Magic the Gathering card on the buylist?

Cavern of Souls has the highest offer on this page at $54.65. Offers change with the market.